Thanks Hyena, it means a lot.
Keats montage is just a bit to long for me. It definitely has some of the best social gameplay I've seen and its giant map selection is unreal. However the edit just gets to me, specifically the clip cutting. I don't care if its the first, third, or final kill there are moments where I just want to experience the clip, but I always find it cutting to something else. Like at the beginning of the third (?) song on Uncaged where its just flips through the kills, I feel it just wants to show me the high multi medal more than anything else or on Damnation with the 360 noscope its a quick cut right before it starts, then effects while its happening its just distracting me from what I really want to see, the 360 no scope. The rest of the edit was great, I felt it had a great use of effects, good angles (love the upside down angles), good transitions.
Summer Colors didn't have as good of gameplay to me, but the editing was more enjoyable. I just felt sucked in by the music and the editing. The music fit right in with the montage name, specifically Summer. The storm on blackout was a nice touch for those summer night rain storms. It just had a great theme and stuck to it, thats what really stood out to me anyways. It was just more of a complete package. Not that it didn't have its own problems, the main thing that bothered me is that it was constantly slowing down clips to fit the music. Though I suppose it just might have to be a sacrifice when you have high multi's. I wouldn't know I've never had that problem haha.
All in all I could have seen either of them moving on. Had I not voted for myself Summer Colors would have gotten my vote, but Keat was a great contender and would have had me guessing.