From what i've seen it is you who is being an obnoxious douchebag. This guy is just defending himself, similar to myself. I dont want to bring that thread into this one, but i've seen you being a dick to a lot of people. Its 2015, halo is pretty much dead. Anyone still playing and putting out their own content gets a thumbs up in my book, regardless of skill. You're walking on thin ice by shitting all over peoples hard work, passions and persuiting goals.
I have nothing wrong with kind criticism, but you always have to finish what you're saying on a positive note, else the criticized become defensive and a very pointless argument ensues.
As for the OP, I do agree that many of your clips were sub par. People have high standards, including myself. The difference is, I actually hit clips and some of them admitted they dont because they hardly play. Which is fine, but a bit hypocritical. I really appreciate all of your dub shots and quad shots. I played OG H2, and MCC is definitely more difficult to pull off to pull off some button glitches. That quadshot for the double top mid on Middy was insane. And it is really hard to get 8man FFA lobbies these days. Keep playing bro, and maybe take that advice of having a shorter, cleaner montage with more quality clips.
Oh, and one more thing. Be sure that the songs you are using arent copywrited. Those songs are pretty popular and youtube could disable the sound on all your videos which is a bitch. Btw, i love that genre of music...far better than the typical dubstep/soft pop people use these days. And that genre is a signature of oldschool h2 montages, which is a GOOD THING :) But i would suggest using lesser known songs by those bands, or lesser known bands. Those songs are a bit mainstream and have been used in lots of montages over the years believe it or not. Again, stay in the genre, but use lesser known songs :) take care bud.